Choki Motobu once remarked that a single kata represented the style of the time. In my opinion, he wasn’t talking about stances and techniques, but something deeper. Motobu was known for his very practical view of fighting. He famously emphasized the importance of Naihanchi, once stating that “Naihanchi is the foundation of karate.” His focus…
Tag: Masters
Walking Your Own Path in Karate
Karate has always evolved. Kata have changed. Methods of teaching have changed. Even within a single generation, subtle differences appear. That was happening long before Westerners ever set foot in an Okinawan dojo. What we can know tends to come from personal experience rather than historical reconstruction. Much of karate back then was not taught as a…
Even Monkeys Fall From Trees – Learning From Mistakes in the Martial Arts
We often learn more from searching for an answer and not finding it than from simply being given the answer itself. It’s not hard to learn more if you are open to it. What is hard is to unlearn something when you discover you may have been doing it wrong all along. I remember over…
Step Off the Centre Line… Then What?
Being attacked with a knife is terrifying. I have seen the results of many of these attacks in my past careers – some of them fatal. And yet most knife defense demonstrations begin the same way. A single, committed middle thrust from distance. Like a standard karate-type stepping punch. No – that’s not how it happens….
The Creed on the Wall.
Most dojos have a creed – a Dojo-Kun (道場訓). A list of promises or ideals, framed neatly on the wall. Students recite it at the start or end of class, bow respectfully, then forget half of it before they reach the car park. That isn’t criticism. It’s just observation. A creed is only words until you…
Realism Is Not Inherited.
Are older systems, older styles, closer to realism? There may be some truth in that. Older systems can preserve deeper material. They can carry forward ideas that were not designed for sport or performance. But age on its own doesn’t guarantee anything. I value lineage. I draw satisfaction from knowing who taught me, and who…
Is the Karate You Practice Really Suitable for Self-Defense?
Almost every promotional video I am sent to watch, or website I am asked to view, mentions one thing – self-defense. Very few say they teach competition. Fewer still say it is primarily for fitness or personal development. Self-defense is the preferred label. There is nothing inherently wrong with that. The problem begins when the content…
Does Kata Work – Or Are We Avoiding What It Demands?
If we don’t understand the applications in kata – are we wasting our time? Someone asked me that recently. It’s a fair question. There is no single, perfect answer to what any movement in kata “is”. Even if the original creator had something specific in mind, that intent is long gone. What remains is the…
What Are You Waiting For?
Karate has changed – we all know that. The karate created by the pioneers on Okinawa looks very different from much of what we see today. And of course, those later pioneers were part of that shift themselves. Change didn’t happen by accident. When I watch students from other dojo trying to work out bunkai…
Lineage Is Not a Substitute for Reality.
I’ve seen a series of so-called self-defense demonstrations doing the rounds on social media recently. They’re being promoted under the banner of a well-known karate lineage. So what? You might say. Well, it matters. Because when a respected name is attached to something, people assume credibility. They assume it must be solid. But that is…
When the Drill Breaks.
Sometimes a student freezes. Not because they don’t know a technique – but because the expected sequence has disappeared. That is the moment training becomes real. In my last article, I wrote that cooperation is not the same as pressure – that structure without uncertainty becomes choreography. The natural question follows. How do we introduce uncertainty…
Cooperation Is Not Pressure.
In my last article, I wrote that before there were kata, there were two people working together. That order matters. But working together is not the same as working under pressure. There is a difference between training with a partner and training against uncertainty. And that difference matters. Many schools spend a great deal of time…