In the world of martial arts, grades are often viewed as a reflection of a practitioner’s journey – a blend of technical ability, deeper understanding, and personal character.

Yet, from time to time, we come across individuals whose grade far outweighs their actual ability, knowledge, or behavior. And when that happens, it’s hard not to feel a sense of frustration. Because something doesn’t sit right.

A grade – whether we like it or not – is an agreement between you and your instructor, or organization. It represents what they teach, and by extension, what you represent.

Nothing more.

If I walked into another dojo, I’m under no illusion that my grade or title would carry much weight. There are no universal standards, and there never have been.

But even within that understanding, there are moments that still raise an eyebrow.

Recently, I saw someone promoted to 5th dan and given the title of Shihan – just five years after achieving shodan. I know this individual. And in my opinion, the depth of understanding, the technical ability, and the way they conduct themselves simply don’t align with that level.

Now, I know – it’s not my place. And yes, money and politics have always had their influence.

But that doesn’t mean it sits well.

Because a grade at that level is supposed to mean something. Not perfection, but a clear depth of experience. A connection to the principles behind the art. A level of responsibility.

Without that, the grade becomes a label without substance.

A belt should never just reflect what someone can do. It should reflect who they are becoming – their humility, their attitude, and how they treat others along the way.

And this is where things become clearer.

Because regardless of what someone wears around their waist, or the title they use, people eventually see what’s there – and what isn’t.

You can’t hide behind a grade forever.

Time has a way of revealing the truth.

Each of us walks our own path. Another person’s promotion – deserved or not – doesn’t take anything away from that. It doesn’t change the work we’ve put in, or the standards we choose to uphold.

So it’s probably not worth carrying the irritation for too long.

But it is worth remembering what actually matters.

Train properly.
Stay honest.
Hold your standards.

Because in the end, a grade without substance is hollow – and no amount of recognition can fill that.

Promotions like these remind me of gravity.

What goes up without foundation… eventually comes down.