In karate we often hear ‘ganbaru’ – do your best, keep going, push through. It’s a useful sentiment, but it doesn’t quite reach the depth of what older martial traditions expected from a practitioner. For that, there is a sterner, more honest practice. It’s called ‘Issho Kenmei’. . It’s not about effort in theory. It…
Tag: Masters
Standards, Verification, and the Responsibilities of Senior Practitioners.
After enough years in the martial arts, you stop asking only what is legitimate, and start asking how legitimacy should be handled. . Senior rank does not just confer authority. It reveals how someone behaves when given the power to accept or reject others. . In every generation of martial arts, there is a tension…
Karate-Do Is Not the Opposite of Practical Karate.
Someone said to me the other day, ‘Why don’t you give up practical karate, as you call it, and just do karate-do?’ . It’s an interesting comment, but one built on a misunderstanding. . What sat beneath the comment was the assumption that karate itself cannot be pragmatic. That once effectiveness and real-world purpose are…
What Makes a Great Teacher – and What Students Carry Forward.
I have been fortunate in my karate journey to have had some truly great teachers. I would say that though, wouldn’t I? No disrespect intended, but I imagine most people feel the same about those who have guided them. . But that raises an important question – what actually makes a great teacher? . A…
When a Black Belt Stops Meaning Anything – and the Outcome Is Already Decided.
There are so many clichés about becoming a black belt, being a black belt, and how you should behave once you eventually get one. . But the problem is that for some people, it doesn’t stop there. One black belt isn’t enough. They want another grade, then another. More stripes on the belt. . When…
Learning Isn’t the Hard Part – When Experience Gets in the Way.
We all want to be acknowledged for our work, our performance, our dedication. It’s a natural human desire to know that we are doing a good job. . Praise is one of those small things that can mean a great deal. Positive reinforcement feels good, and there’s nothing wrong with that. But it can also…
Predictable Responses Are Not Guaranteed Outcomes.
Following my recent article on bunkai and choreography, I found myself returning to the idea of “predictable responses”. It’s a familiar concept, and on the surface it makes sense. Certain actions often provoke certain reactions. . But often isn’t always. Nothing is guaranteed. . Yes, bodies respond to input. Strike, pull, disrupt balance – something…
Bunkai Without Reaction Is Still Choreography.
Bunkai – in some circles it is getting better. Practitioners and instructors are beginning to understand the reality of violence rather than relying on the familiar, stylized karate-type attacks. Intent, distance, and targets are improving. In others, however, there is still a long way to go. . But something fundamental is still missing in many…
What Do We Mean When We Say “Original Kata”?
This question comes up again and again in karate, usually after a video is shared or a book is mentioned. Someone performs a kata and the discussion quickly turns into claims about what is “original”, who learned from whom, and who was closest to the source. Before long, the kata itself is almost forgotten, replaced…
Certificates, Curiosity, and the Disappearance of Depth in Karate.
There is a modern belief that achievement is something you can hold in your hand – a certificate, a diploma, a grade, a title, a rank. Something printed, stamped, and signed that proves you have arrived. It’s a comforting illusion, and it has taken root in karate. . The logic is simple. If the box…
When Function Comes First – Kata as Record, Not Puzzle.
History is a strange thing. We have snippets here and there, sometimes probabilities creep in, but very little that is truly concrete. We study, we interpret, and some attempt to reverse engineer, but at the end of the day we can only work with what we have now. . There is an ongoing discussion around…
Choreography and the Dangers of Untested Confidence.
I was watching a video of a practitioner going through some self-defense techniques, presented as coming from a respected karate legacy. . To be honest, it would have been totally ineffective for that goal. . In a recent article, I explained how, as a young man in my early 20s, actively competing at a national…